zudo-led-lamp
GitHub repository

Type to search...

to open search from anywhere

Component Selection Guidelines — Draft

Cost and availability guidance for the two-unit LED plan; locally retained; engineering recommendations remain draft.

Locally integrated on 2026-10-24 from the reviewed draft; engineering recommendations remain draft and no hardware selection is adopted. This page supplements the BOM and dated cost history, not the exact evidence owners. Route additions/substitutions through .claude/skills/component-spec-audit/ and its inventory; use circuit-spec-integration for real cross-component consequences. Do not hand-edit generated component records.

Confirmed user decisions

  • Two finished lamps; prioritize reuse of the two existing assembled Board Ls. Their health is not yet established. The old PD failure is not evidence that Board L failed, and it does not justify buying two replacement Board Ls.

  • Current isolated input direction is HUSB238_006DD, 15 V-only, LED-first/common Board P. General USB-C form is accepted with required PD capability stated; no specific charger/cable model prerequisite and no claim every USB-C source supports 15 V. Do not add 12 V fallback operation.

  • Prefer inexpensive, ample-stock ordinary JLC parts that meet actual requirements. Compare separately sourced IC/socket routes when a large price difference exists; the user regards insertion effort as small.

  • M-12 is a candidate, not confirmed mounting geometry. Historical STUSB/M-17 records and the old “Final BOM” remain history; they are not silently restored as the current HUSB candidate. Separate PD Board A/SBP-001 is not this LED body or shared Board P.

These decisions are recorded in the 2026-10-23 handoff and 2026-10-24 coordinator instruction led-moya-component-guidance-draft-90e616f9-a543-4f55-8edd-1ad356f67439. The immutable draft packet retains their provenance; local integration records these user directions without adopting candidate hardware.

Draft recommendations: cost and availability first

Start with circuit requirements, then compare a small shortlist of inexpensive, widely stocked JLCPCB orderables before committing the design to a costly or obscure part. For ordinary interchangeable parts, match value, package, tolerance, working voltage, power and dielectric requirements. Prefer Basic when its actual assembly cost makes the total lower; a tier label alone does not decide suitability or cost. Do not spend an exhaustive brand comparison on a low-stress ordinary resistor or hold its source selection for unrelated physical measurements.

Scale the review to function. Precision feedback/sensing, timing, audio-critical paths, storage/low-leakage nodes and high-stress or ambiguous applications need the specific relevant limits: for example TCR, voltage coefficient, leakage, noise, ESR/stability, effective capacitance, pulse energy or thermal limits. Engineering must derive these from the circuit and exact sources; do not ask the user to invent limits or silently relax a justified requirement to select a cheaper part.

Before selecting, record exact manufacturer, complete orderable MPN/suffix, package and pin map, supplier code, quantity basis, source URL and observation date. Separate catalog listing, current stock, assembly eligibility, lead time and user-owned inventory. Compare total delivered/assembled cost including minimum quantity, unavoidable surplus, setup/placement charges, shipping and tax. Preserve unknown charges explicitly. Recheck dated evidence when a real purchase is prepared; this draft contains no live stock check or current quote.

Draft recommendations: compare socket routes explicitly

Compare these routes early when an IC dominates cost. A socket does not itself reduce the chip price, and a DIP version or pin-compatible adapter is not assumed.

RouteIdentify and countActual work and material effects
Direct SMT PCBAExact IC, board footprint, fitted quantity and assembler chargesFactory placement/soldering; package heat path and assembly constraints
Separately sourced genuine DIP plus socketExact genuine DIP orderable, socket pitch/width/pin count, IC/socket quantities and supplier termsSocket must be soldered by the permitted assembler, then IC inserted; check height/clearance, retention and relevant contact/current or leakage limits
Identified SMD adapter plus socketExact SMD IC, adapter circuit/pin mapping, adapter PCB/assembly and compatible socketState who solders IC to adapter and socket to main PCB, and who inserts it; include extra area/height, heat path, relevant parasitics/leakage and contacts

For a two-finished-unit comparison, start with twice the actual placements of each IC/socket/adapter, subtract only established reusable inventory, then apply each supplier's actual MOQ and excess requirements. Keep installed demand and purchase quantity separate. If the project's final quantity differs, recompute rather than carry over this comparison scenario.

The user considers insertion effort minor. Do not dismiss substantial verified savings with a generic labor penalty or hypothetical reliability warning. List the actual soldering/insertion steps and any circuit-specific effect that changes the choice; do not assign an hourly cost without evidence or user direction. A factory-only soldering requirement, where applicable, remains separate from manual socket insertion: insertion permission does not authorize hand-soldering a socket or adapter. Check the project's assembly contract before proposing that route.

Unresolved choices and evidence boundary

No replacement part, socket, DIP variant, adapter, assembler or supplier is selected by this guidance. Additional parent review may follow; do not invent prior approvals or describe every costly historical part as a proven mistake. Keep confirmed user decisions separate from recommendations and inherited engineering assumptions. A candidate BOM identity does not authorize canonical adoption, manufacturing or product acceptance. Existing electrical and physical qualification gates remain attached to the relevant design, not to every unrelated ordinary part.

Dated user evidence and selection record

The coordinator supplied two earlier user directions: 2026-10-23 10:21 UTC, select as cheaply as suitable by circuit location and consider sockets for expensive ICs; 10:27 UTC, investigate expensive/obscure choices before selection and treat insertion as minor work. The JPY1000-to-JPY100 example expresses a preference for large material savings; it is not a supplier quote. Evidence IDs are Sentinel_bc24f83491c4819182c58425045a7a9e and Sentinel_83405254a0988191a187f6627a2d261b, relayed in led-moya-guidance-user-evidence-b492dc8f-f27b-425e-acb1-589d5fd45542. Socketing is an option, not a goal: prefer a suitable cheaper SMT route when its total cost already wins. Connector contact/interface/mounting compatibility must be established for the exact counterpart; it is not generic resistor substitution.

Keep one short dated record per actual choice:

RecordRequired content
Use and requirementsCircuit location/function; justified limits and their source
Identity and quantityManufacturer, exact MPN/JLC code/package; placements, finished-unit count, reusable inventory and purchase-quantity basis
Commercial observationPrice, stock, Basic/Extended/category, assembly eligibility and lead time, date and URL; fees/tax/shipping/MOQ limits
DecisionSuitable alternatives considered, reason, concrete tradeoffs and remaining unknowns

No new numeric spending cap or exhaustive brand comparison is required.

Existing evidence to reuse

The BOM labels its JLC snapshot 2026-07-25, header observations 2026-08-20 and control changes 2026-09-06. Its old Extended-fee/reorder arithmetic must not be presented as today's quote or used to authorize removing protections. The architecture overview and exact owner records provide design context, not proof of as-built health.

The isolated V15 installed BOM has 25 physical parts per new input candidate, 50 for two, grouped into 20 orderable rows; two source-only flags are excluded. It records zero new Board L builds and leaves order quantities unset. This is a source snapshot, not a procurement approval. The retained M-12 observation on 2026-10-23 was quantity two, displayed total JPY58, MOQ1 at JLC C165948. It excludes verified shipping, assembly and tax terms and is not refreshed here. Do not use it as proof of current stock or physical fit.

Revision History

CreatedUpdated